Mafia 21.

Here are my thoughts: (k.s. - keywords)
Night 1
Order of actions:
1. Sorceress (block), --------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seductress. ND1, - to Madge (k.s. spirits)
Barbarian, - to Naera (I associate a lot of people with the Barbarian)
Captain of the Guard - Madge - a quite respectable person. – Madge was blocked from him, no action.
2. Sorceress (defense) ------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Seductress. ND2 (not displayed in the newspaper) -------------------------------
4. Avenger. ND1 (not displayed in the newspaper) --------------------------------
5. Royal Guard - to Hermit (guarding the house)
6. Warrior (if defense was not required - not displayed in the newspaper) ----------
7. Informant - to Guru
8. Werewolf ------------
9. Avenger. ND2
10. Pirate -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11. Outcast ND1 – to Madge
12. Executioner -----------
13. Warlock ---------
14. Stalker --------
15. Nameless --------
16. Assassin ----------
17. Sorceress (healing), - to Aru ((keywords: shortly before, magical, beauty)
Paladin, - to Aru (k.s.: light)
Outcast ND2 (displayed in the newspaper only if healing from poison was required) ----

It seems like everything fits. In general, I would risk assigning someone from the Hermit/Naera pair, provided that the murders did not go into natural/artificial defenses, then they are the first candidates!