Heroes 6 - Discussion

It would be even better to divide physical damage into piercing, slashing, bludgeoning, fire, acid/poison, and astral, and magical damage into elements.
And also add a penalty for shooting at each cell.

I think sarcasm is inappropriate.
In Heroes of Might and Magic, some creatures already had similar vulnerabilities and resistances. Mainly to spells, although, if I'm not mistaken, creature attacks were also taken into account (I definitely remember that in the fourth game, phoenixes, darklings, and fire elementals had fire damage as a skill). It's just that in King's Bounty, the system is clearly and understandably systematized. And yes, I like this systematization of skills.

And it's better to leave the shooting penalty as a classic one. And all magical projectiles should hit without a penalty. I'm not arguing, it's realistic in the fourth game, but as a fan of ranged combat, I cringe at the sight of colossal penalties.