1. Against. Let's say I decide to organize something with a claim to creativity, like "Fathers and Sons-4" or "Andra vs Rion" - should I ask the AC for permission to include Vitalik in the tournament? No way. 2. Leave Jed alone. It's quite dubious that he was banned without investigation and then rewarded; just calm down about it.

HermitThe final decision on awarding technical fault in disputed situations always rests with the AC, not the organizer.

Unfortunately, this is not always the case. That's what the poll is about. The final word was, is, and should be with the organizer.