Skip to content

Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

User Avatar
#363
Auto-translated
Kash
I've said this before, and I'm saying it again, and I'll probably have to repeat it many times.
The current rule should not just be "possible," but necessary to be interpreted this way: for all questions and misunderstandings, players in this tournament should contact me, and not wherever they feel like. I am against them contacting the Arbitration Committee (AK) without my knowledge. I consider myself to be sufficiently reasonable and competent to resolve minor disputes, suspicions, and answer questions about the game. If I have any doubts, of course, I will contact you. It's not normal that I am "willing to resolve controversial situations" myself. It's normal that I resolve them.

A little off-topic.
I'm aware of the issue with V. When did he contact you? Two weeks ago? Three? Did you even look at the saves from that time? The guy is upset, says he'll leave the forum, nobody cares. I understand that you're busy, you have work, it's hard to get organized, etc., I'm not saying anything. But I don't have time to wait 3 weeks - the tournament started yesterday, and there are people who have already played 2 rounds.

In general, in this tournament, I am the organizer, the judge, and the highest authority. I create the rules, make the draws, and resolve disputes. In the tournament thread, only reports and posts from the organizer are not considered off-topic; I have the right to delete everything else as off-topic. If you don't like it, create your own tournaments and run them.

No! In your tournament, as in all other tournaments, the highest authority is the AK! Why, if a player is a beginner, can't he contact the AK? Why can other players, but not beginners? What kind of discrimination and self-judgment is this? Who do you think you are? You can certainly resolve controversial situations, but if a player wants the AK to investigate, that is his right, and it is the AK's duty to intervene and investigate. And the players should know this! For example, you refused to let readme participate in the tournament, and he felt that your decision was unfair and left the forum. I don't understand why he didn't contact the AK...

Added 8 minutes later
And regarding the fact that there's no time to wait, all organizers are busy. So why did we create the AK in the first place? It's the same thing, you're all busy, so you don't have time to wait for it to sort things out
Всё не так плохо как Вы думаете. Всё намного хуже!