I'm also starting to doubt between Werevolk and Thorium. Both versions seem plausible, probably because they are similar. It's all just literature.
For now, my vote is to execute Thorium.
P.S. I understand when the Mafia votes illogically – of course, it's more pleasant for them to hang the Town member. But how the Town can forgive itself for such mistakes is completely unclear.
"Oh well, it seems Thorium was a Town member after all," TaKo will write after his death, "what a pity..." The others won't say anything at all, as if that's exactly what should have happened.
Added 4 minutes later
Ellina, Werevolk, Pandora, do you really think that all you had to do was look at what novels Palanik wrote to find a clue?
Added 1 minute later
6 out of 19 people voted; this is a disaster. We won't hang anyone, not even me