Everyone is asking for the AK's opinion, so I'll share my perspective:
1) There was a request to the AK with undeniable evidence of cheat codes in an online game!
- It's not worth rushing to conclusions and first find out what happened from the owner of that computer.
The response was that it was a guest, and the owner is not involved.
- Well, no one could have thought of that/I still don't believe he could have cheated, I just don't believe it./

Now, my decision on this situation/I was looking for it in ICQ, but I only found a shortened version/:

Pit (11:11:00 10/02/2010)
regarding Alex?
Scorp (11:11:30 10/02/2010)
we still need the time of the last save, Numuan
Scorp (11:11:47 10/02/2010)
if it's close, I would suggest a replay
Scorp (11:12:00 10/02/2010)
I don't think Alex did it

And the full interpretation was, it all depends on the opponent's decision - either continue the match or have a replay.

2) My second decision was:
technically - after studying the evidence and comparing the time on the video and the saves.

3) All that was required from Cobra was to confirm Alex's alibi, and that's it.
What information was obtained and how it was obtained - based on this,
my opinion has remained the same, and disqualification should only be from the tournament.

4) And finally, the opinion was:
Alex should be suspended from tournaments for six months, and Cobra for three months.
The unacceptable action that occurred on Alex's computer is not considered cheating, but rather unacceptable fan behavior/example: fans rioting in a stadium - the management of the team whose fans are involved is responsible.//There is no evidence that Cobra did it, and it has not been proven that it was Alex - maybe someone saw something that Alex is being punished for cheating./ To resolve this situation, all that was needed was for Cobra to confirm Alex's alibi.



Now, all you WISE and JUST people, put yourselves in the judge's shoes and suggest a solution to the situation - I will gladly listen and try to understand/maybe I'm not very good at judging, and it's time to give up my powers, if that's the case, I'll write a resignation from the AK./

P.S.: I don't know how my vote could have been for the World Championship, I hope Dirty made a typo:
Pit (16:28:23 6/03/2010)
i.e., you think that all these inconsistencies in their statements are not evidence of Alex's cheating? and should we punish them for unethical behavior of the player and his fan?
Scorp (16:28:59 6/03/2010)
exactly

P.P.S.: I still don't believe that Alex did it, my opinion/punishment/is only for unacceptable behavior!

P.P.P.S.: such a punishment is not specified in the rules - for the first time, I would still give penalty sanctions and still disqualify him from the tournament - it should not be the norm that cheat codes are entered on the same computer with a 3-minute difference from the online game/on a different computer, please, but not in the presence of the player in that room!

I hope you understand what I wanted to convey... I wish everyone understanding and fewer insults, please