In my opinion, it's obvious that Light will win the vote.

Why is it obvious?)
Light is basically the same as Sod, consider it. I, for example, would never vote for him.
I would suggest a version where the players agree on a pair. If there's no compromise, the judge flips a coin.
And why exactly 5 templates? The selection and voting scheme also needs to be discussed by all players, not "here, take it, vote for 5, 10, 12 templates, etc."

It's all just my opinion.
P.S. There's no need to badmouth Captain. Pushing someone through and so on. It has nothing to do with him.