Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

I fixed his little bird for him :) Guys, let's not do that. We'll scold him, and that's it. We'll figure it out :)

Added 2 hours 42 minutes ago

And he was demanding a technical victory over Enik, even though it was annoying and rude, but IMHO, it was still fair.

maxlewis suddenly started demanding a technical victory on 12/29, out of nowhere. Here's what happened before:

Enik (20:07:05 12/18/2009)
Hi))

Kash (20:07:16 12/18/2009)
Hi =)

Enik (20:07:52 12/18/2009)
Will maxlewis from our group be replaced?

Enik (20:08:10 12/18/2009)
Or can we negotiate with him?

Kash (20:08:29 12/18/2009)
I don't know yet how his internet is. Try talking to him.

Kash (20:08:48 12/18/2009)
If you can connect, play, I won't replace him.

Enik (20:08:57 12/18/2009)
Okay
.....

Kash (16:24:11 12/20/2009)
Hi, have you played with Maxlewis yet?

Kash (16:24:26 12/20/2009)
maxlewis

Enik (17:47:40 12/20/2009)
Hi

Enik (17:47:55 12/20/2009)
Not yet, we agreed for tomorrow.

Kash (17:48:12 12/20/2009)
Okay =)
.....

Enik (12:25:44 12/24/2009)
Hi

Enik (12:26:33 12/24/2009)
Damn, it's really inconvenient for me, but I won't be able to finish the game.

Enik (12:29:16 12/24/2009)
I'm leaving today, and I couldn't connect with anyone. Yesterday, we sat for 3 hours trying to connect via Hamachi, GameRanger, and direct IP address(((

Enik (12:29:40 12/24/2009)
I'm so sorry I let you down(((((((

Kash (12:35:00 12/24/2009)
Hi. It's okay =) Thanks for letting me know. Have a good trip =)

Enik (12:36:21 12/24/2009)
Thank you)

Now, tell me, am I supposed to dig around and figure out who's to blame for the bad connection? And whose fault is it that each pair of participants couldn't play? Do you see how much space the logs of the negotiations take up for just ONE game? And can you imagine how much of this I have to read through? This isn't a complaint. I enjoy chatting with Enik, Dariel_Lich, Ney Drake, Vampire, I'm always willing to explain something to Ivengo or Marazhan, I always answer questions from all the Maxim's, I solve problems in games, etc. Why am I also obligated to report, post logs, explain something, and justify my actions? It was said: all those who didn't play will receive a technical result. This applies to everyone equally. When I tried to introduce a different template in the playoffs, I was immediately told to refer to the first post, and they wrote a bunch of nasty things in the database, etc. Okay. We play by the rules. Didn't play - zero. That's it.

I also don't understand why Redwhait couldn't play with me in Might and Magic vs. Magic, and I also got a zero...

Volodya, don't confuse apples and oranges. This is a completely different situation. It's a fan-made fun event, without any formalities. What other technical results could there be? What is this nonsense about technical results? I understand if it's an Olympics, they agreed, and one person didn't show up. Someone needs to advance - technical result. But here, why should a victory be awarded, I don't know. Well, I've ranted a bit. :) Actually, I'm in a good pre-holiday mood, I just earned 600 bucks for a gift for my girlfriend (what a big mouth!))) ... Now I'll just sit down and summarize the results, I don't have any strength left, to be honest... Well, okay, happy upcoming holidays! Now I'll only rant in the New Year. :) All the best!