Skip to content

Mafia: general discussions.

User Avatar
#465
Auto-translated
This wording eliminates the very possibility of bluffing and also negates the actions of town roles that investigate (since checking someone who hasn't killed anyone yet won't provide any useful information for the investigation, and voting against them cannot be justified according to the rules, which, in my opinion, is not good). I would suggest the following wording (while still adhering to the current rules):

It is forbidden to directly reveal your own or someone else's role by shouting things like "I am the Doctor," "He is Mafia," or to directly transmit information you have received, specifying the type of action: "I checked Kolya," "I healed," "according to information that I cannot disclose," etc.

Hints (even very obvious ones) about your own/someone else's role/actions are not prohibited: whether true or false. ("It is quite possible that someone investigated Vasya, and judging by the votes against him, the investigator may be among them - therefore, let's execute Vasya," "I think Kolya has information, which is why he is voting this way - let's listen to his opinion," etc.)

It is allowed to refer to the rules, the GM, your own posts, or the posts of other players, as well as any external sources where you found some information based on the clues.

That's why I suggested several variations of rule sets.
Not everyone likes psychological Mafia - this option is in the minority here, but it is not rejected.
In the right hands and with the right mindset, even under these conditions, you can share investigation results. Moreover, investigation has another purpose - understanding other roles, narrowing the circle of suspects.

Added after 49 seconds
It seems there is no way to fight this =/ What are these lists?

Lists of notorious offline players and rule-breakers. It's a necessary thing.

Наше оружие - неожиданность! Неожиданность и страх, страх и неожиданность - это два наших оружия! Плюс безжалостность - три наших оружия: страх, неожиданность и безжалостность! И ещё фанатичная преданность Папе - четвёртое! Наше оружие включает в себя... наше оружие включает в себя... страх, неожиданность... я сейчас!