Wedma
Auto-translated
8. It is forbidden to reveal your own/another player's role, or its elements, as well as any information obtained about it, in public places or among players who are not in the same group as you. The same applies to information about other players. Phrases like "well, I know something about him that I can't say" are a violation, regardless of whether you actually know something or are lying.
Statements like "I checked," "according to my information, which I cannot disclose," "I know for sure," etc., are prohibited. Unsubstantiated shouts like "he's MAFIA!" or "I'm a VILLAGER!" are allowed.
To avoid violating this rule, try to express your thoughts as assumptions or as IMHO, based, for example, on clues or behavior.
It is allowed to refer to the rules, the GM, your own posts, or the posts of other players, as well as to any external sources where you found information about the clues.
This wording eliminates the possibility of bluffing and also negates the actions of city-based investigative roles (since checking a mafia member who hasn't killed anyone yet won't provide useful information for the investigation, and voting against him is prohibited by the rules, which, in my opinion, is not good). I would suggest the following wording (while still adhering to the current rules):
It is forbidden to directly reveal your own/another player's role by shouting things like "I'm the Doctor," "He's Mafia," or to directly transmit information you have obtained, indicating the type of action: "I checked Kolya," "I healed," "according to my information, which I cannot disclose," etc.
Hints (even very obvious ones) about your own/another player's role/actions are not prohibited, whether true or false. ("It is quite possible that the investigator was with Vasya, and judging by the votes against him, the investigator may be among them - therefore, let's execute Vasya," "I think Kolya has information, which is why he is voting like that - let's listen to his opinion," etc.)
It is also allowed to refer to the rules, the GM, your own posts, or the posts of other players, as well as to any external sources where you found information about the clues.
• Discussing the game outside of this thread (i.e., in private messages, ICQ, etc.) is only allowed if you have a role that permits it. In this game, only the Mafia has this possibility.
1. The GM is always right.
2. If the GM is not right, see rule 1.
If you have written something in the rules, you should follow it until the end of the game.
• A player who does not vote after 12 hours of the game day is considered to have voted against themselves.
_ I sleep for 12 hours on weekends....
I would suggest allowing players to cancel their votes and, in no case, reduce the length of the day.
And finally, a question: what is the point of investigative roles in the current rules? To obtain information for yourself, but not to be allowed to use it? Because attempts to find flimsy evidence can lead to accusations of searching for barbarians and being a member of the Mafia. It's easier for investigators to remain silent.
P.S. Of course, to understand how the rules work, they need to be tested in practice, which I hope to do after the game *who is last in line?=*.
Let's discuss...
Если кто-то тебе противоречит, подумай: может, он не прав? (с)
Говорят, что рыжие не плачут,
Говорят, душа у них - огонь.
Если влюблены, то любят значит,
Если ненавидят - их не тронь!
"Не заблуждайтесь. Рыжие - это зло! Знаете кто был рыжим? Иуда... Что сделал Иуда? Иисуса предал - вот что! Я говорю вслух то, о чем другие только думают. Рыжие опасны. И однажды ночью, когда вы будете спать в своих кроватках, рыжие придут за вами... Они придут за вами!!!"
(с) Эрик Картман
Говорят, что рыжие не плачут,
Говорят, душа у них - огонь.
Если влюблены, то любят значит,
Если ненавидят - их не тронь!
"Не заблуждайтесь. Рыжие - это зло! Знаете кто был рыжим? Иуда... Что сделал Иуда? Иисуса предал - вот что! Я говорю вслух то, о чем другие только думают. Рыжие опасны. И однажды ночью, когда вы будете спать в своих кроватках, рыжие придут за вами... Они придут за вами!!!"
(с) Эрик Картман