Мафия 9. Mage Valley

yes, I also tend to agree with Zubr's version, and I agree with the strange accusations against the Sorceress, because her signature already appeared in the evidence from the previous Mafia game, and it is unlikely that she is guilty of the murder. By the way, if an Animagus was following Liz (who kills Mafia members if they go on a mission), then Liz couldn't have been killed. (Hermit seems to have been building theories about him).
In theory, Hosa has a higher chance of being the Mafia, because the magical artifact showing time from the second murder can also be attributed to him (he has a watch on his robe), i.e., two pieces of evidence from two murders, and if one is wrong, then the other may be correct... but it's still not worth rushing to conclusions.