Here's what they said on their forum:
It's clear that he didn't break any rules... It's just nonsense about these scrolls... I don't understand why you haven't banned him completely. We've always played by the Chaos rules - scrolls up to 221 are simply banned (level 4-5). The worst thing is that I found a Potion of Life! This is just ridiculous... Instead of an elixir, I now have a butt :cool:
Anyway, I give up... The final straw was the maximum-level tree. In the first two rounds, there were so many morale boosts that I couldn't take it with 4 angels with 12-4 stats against Vali with expert offense... Sorry, guys... You can't win against a generator, no matter how you play... I have saves, and I don't think anyone would dare to throw a stone at me...