For example, Alex_R, who once convinced me that calculating damage in battles is completely unnecessary (and couldn't say how much damage 200 Troglodytes deal:)), has an incredibly high win percentage. And on the other hand, there are people whose game skill is higher than their win rate.

Yes, Pash, you're right about Alex:) , I remember in my only game with him, where due to my profound noobness (only played for the 2nd month) I lost on 117 even though the game was going pretty well for me, and the funniest part is that he also lost:D, because he supposedly planned to go for angels on the 1st via smk and to ramp up the pace attacked 20-49 elves on the grass - just a fatherly game, nothing to say;) . And his comment about taking the max Griffin Conservatory at Neoendi for swamp without oil on the 2nd was especially amusing: he said he lost a lot of gnolls there - basically implied that 4 angels aren't worth losing 80 or 90 gnolls:D ...

And you're also right about unlucky people, whose real skill is higher than their win rate. There are quite a few of them.