Is 3D necessary in Heroes 3.59?

In order not to clutter someone else's topic, I am moving the discussion here.

1)http://forum.df2.ru/index.php?showtopic=9205
2) Those who played Heroes 3
3) Read the Professor's statements and understand why the release of HotA beta was postponed
4) What is unclear here? It's just ordinary propaganda and advertising. There are no news reports about Heroes 3 because nothing interesting has happened for a long time.
5) I know that many people play Heroes 1 and 2; this is because not everyone in Russia is a millionaire.
6) Of course, it's my fault that what matters most to me is the gameplay process, not how it looks. Although Heroes 3 has very beautiful graphics, which is its advantage over part 2.
7) Technically, it is impossible to remake Heroes 3 on a 3D engine unless you completely redo it, but why would you?

8) Example of foreign graphics in Heroes /post/287222/
It looks good, but it's still not 3D, although it already resembles Heroes 4. 9) If you want to help, contribute with graphics.
10) In Bastion, all graphic developments are available in 3D, but due to point 7, we will be playing the same 2D game

1) I read it. So? Yes, the work deserves respect (which I have said more than once). But where is the answer to the question of why they don't make it in 3D? Is it because they want to preserve the graphics close to those of "Heroes 3"? That is, could they create a three-dimensional add-on?
2) What do those who played "Heroes 5" say?
3) I read everything I found from your link, but I didn't understand why it was postponed.
4) This is understandable. The other thing is unclear. Do you think that if "Heroes 3" (3.59) were advertised as much as "Heroes 5" at one time, would "Heroes 5" withstand the competition?
5) Poor people don't play at all. But computers are becoming very cheap quickly, and now a computer on which you can play "Heroes 5" costs very little. Why discuss this again and again?
6) I am also interested in the gameplay process (perhaps even when this long-awaited add-on finally comes out, I will forget about the three-dimensional "Heroes 5" after playing it – it will be so interesting), but graphics are also important. I never got more pleasure from a game than when I played 3.58. And if all this were also in 3D, then I probably would have completely forgotten about the existence of the real world. Perhaps we can say that "Heroes 5" is a three-dimensional "Heroes 3," but definitely not a three-dimensional WOG.
7) I haven't seen any decent mods for "Heroes 5" yet that would make "Heroes 5" comparable to 3.58 (in terms of gameplay). Maybe they will appear later, but for now... Or maybe I just didn't search well enough for these mods.
8) It looks good. Will the add-on really look like this? I would like to see what they have done.
9) I can't do it yet. I need another year to reach a decent level of modeling. For now, I'm just learning. I already know some things, but there is still much to learn.
10) No comment needed here.
In general, I don't see the point of this argument. There is no prospect for me in it because, regardless of what conclusion we come to (we may or may not come to one), "Heroes 3.59" will not become three-dimensional.