Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

Auto-translated

Pit for LM

Here are the rules for reviewing situations involving suspicions of unfair play:
/topic/at/271167/
It was posted on July 22, 2009. Players had no complaints regarding any of the points.

Mage Guild, in this case, point 7 was violated:

7. If the members of the Arbitration Committee believe that the accusations are justified, then a publicly accessible topic is created on a resource independent of Heroes Community (ХВ), where all materials submitted by the accusing party are placed, edited so that nowhere does it contain the nickname of either the suspect or the accuser. This topic is created to create a complete and objective picture - accusations, defense, involvement of independent experts, public discussion. A link to the topic is sent to interested parties and everyone who wishes.

I highlighted what was violated on the forum. And as a result, we got what we got. I personally have serious doubts about the objectivity of the decision made on the forum.
That's why I suggest conducting an independent investigation on our portal. Since anonymity can no longer be maintained, I propose a format for reviewing the situation in a separate thread, where only members of the Arbitration Committee and the accused can post. And based on this investigation, a decision should be made.

Good luck.