Skip to content

Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

User Avatar
#77
Auto-translated
Dirty_Player
Alex, please do me a favor, take a look at the saves. There are many more questions there...
I read that thread and even wanted to try to answer all the questions, as I immediately noticed that, for example, questions 135 and 147 contain nothing criminal, and the harassment from Neo simply shows that he considers himself to be in a position where "objections are not accepted" and "the explanation is absurd."
Neo is definitely overdoing it.
But the subsequent questions turned out to be more serious; if everything is described there as it really is, then there is no need to look at the saves... logically, the "luck" is too consistent, although, as I understand it, this is more like examining the saves between games than during the game itself. It is practically impossible to prove that he might be using map hacks, but the number of questions really raises doubts about Vitalik's honesty, but I cannot 100% assert anything without playing with him personally.
Dirty_Player
Let's do this. Let's have a poll: "Are you satisfied with the actions of the AK?" Let's look at the results; if there are many against, then we will close this shop without regret!!
This is a pointless exercise. The AK is held together solely by the authority of its representatives; the organization itself and the decisions made are mediocre, but the goal is not to shut down the AK, but to make it function properly.
P.S. I cannot run Tournaments; I know it's not easy, and I'm not putting pressure on the deadline for resolving the problems I submitted... solve other issues, I will wait as long as necessary, but not using methods like deleting only my posts.

Added 4 minutes ago
Kash
There was no reason to ban here. Either it should have been stopped somehow earlier.
Points were awarded according to the rules (no one was banned).
I just don't understand what "should have been done earlier" means.
That is, if you let it go, then it is no longer relevant to fix the violations?