Skip to content

Autosaves: Should they be enabled or not?

#28
Auto-translated
KostyaN
I really don't understand this logic: "winning by letting your opponent lose isn't a real win," but letting yourself lose and then using auto-combat on them is okay? :D In my opinion, it should be the other way around, IMHO. I understand that people often play more for fun than for ranking, but you shouldn't confuse the two. It's one thing to fight a combined enemy army that they split up for scouting or clearing a resource point and then they just got caught (that shouldn't count, obviously), but it's completely different to win because they underestimated the neutral creatures (and then this "noble player" will even post the victory :D and somehow climb in the ranking :confused:). I guess it's not my problem if the opponent attacked something they shouldn't have and lost. In the worst case, if my conscience wakes up and the situation is really hopeless, I can finish the game without it counting or start a new one, but I won't post this one (it's happened before - that's just my IMHO, and it's much better). I think I've said everything.
+100. I don't think you can call someone a "great player" if they lose to neutral creatures, especially when those neutral creatures are easily dealt with. And underestimating the strength of neutral creatures is also a sign of low skill. Excuses like "I was distracted" or "I didn't notice how many there were" just don't hold up, because I've never heard of really strong players like DC_Vasya, Paladin, Stinger, and MikeSpb having anything like that happen. IMHO, a player's skill level is determined by the number of auto-combats they request. I personally keep my own statistics on requested auto-combats and try to eliminate them, but it's not always as successful as I'd like, but it's still happening:
out of my 41 games:
in the last 20, I requested auto-combat 4 times, once in 4 games (the last one was 3 games ago against Bayazet).
in the later 21st game, I requested auto-combat 11 times, once in 6 games, twice in 1 game (Markon), and three times in 1 game (the highly publicized case :D with DirectX).
I always give auto-combat (this is more because I play with trusted opponents), except for one specific case that everyone has heard about :smile28: and which falls under the "great player" scenario.

Moderated: OFF-TOPIC in the message


P.S. I don't think I wrote anything bad, I didn't want to offend anyone, I was just expressing my personal IMHO on this issue, but knowing how KVERTI feels about this, will he ban me for it?:confused: :confused: :confused: