Pit for LM
Auto-translated
Based on the previous discussion. It seems no one objects to the general name "Tournament Committee". Let's confirm it.
I hope we will soon receive the Creator's blessing and permission to organize a section for the Tournament Committee. The request was sent yesterday.
Each Commission will decide its own name. The NC are already deciding. And they have already started working. The interest in newcomers is encouraging.
Organizing Committees. There's no need to argue about the exact number of tournaments. We need to draw up a schedule for holding traditional tournaments - that's not difficult, communicate with potential Organizers, wait for proposals from the NC. IMHO, if tournaments differ in themes, one won't interfere with another. For example, ClanWar and a Team tournament are naturally never held at the same time. Or it is known that InterPortal and a contest for the best report are planned for the end of the year. Obviously, team competitions cannot be held simultaneously with IP. But an IP is not an obstacle for a tournament for newcomers.
It is important to discuss the format and timing of the traditional Main HeroesWorld tournament.
And one more thing. I do not like it when, in a topic discussing the Rules of tournaments, people I respect start insulting each other out of the blue. I ask you to refrain from this.
Results of the elections to the Appeal Commission of the Tournament Committee.
A total of 38 people voted: bRitvo4kA, Pit for LM, He3Hauka, Dirty_Player, Дубровин Павел, Sem 56, SpiriTT, <аноним1>, Hermit, еwgeniy, LeBron, OUTLAW, Деконтаминатор, Psyche_7, КостяN, Alex_R, redwhait, Captain, Nagan-4, vbn, Kash, Ta Kotoraya..., Mizrael, Wlk777, Oelm, Wicc, RAPER, invisible, Neoandy, Alone, Javdet, scorp, Aldegir, KobRa_RR, Revan, Lider1, Avern, Smoke_mk.
(the first number is FOR, the second is AGAINST, the third is % FOR, the fourth is % AGAINST (% rounded to tenths))
1. Alex_R - 22-10 - 57.9-26.3
2. Mizrael - 21-0 - 55.3-0
3. LeBron - 25-3 - 65.8-7.9
4. Pit for LM - 36-0 - 94.7-0
5. scorp - 23-1 - 60.5-2.6
6. vbn - 32-0 - 84.2-0
7. Дубровин Павел - 27-3 - 71.1-7.9
8. Dirty Player - 23-0 - 60.5-0
In one of the previous posts, respected Alex_R recused himself. But he expressed readiness to help the AC in its work.
Additionally, votes were cast for:
Nagan-4 - +7
invisible - +8-1
Javdet - +6
Dreamcatcher - +3
Loi - +2
ewgeniy - +2
Ta Kotoraya... - +4-4
Oelm - +1
Wicc - +1
Uran - +1
Now regarding the numerical composition. More or less specifically, 18 voters (47.4%) were FOR a "seven", 5 people (13.2%) were FOR a "five". The remaining 15 either expressed nothing at all, or formulated it as: if 5 - then for this one, if 7 - then plus ...
Based on the above, I propose to approve the composition of the AC as 7 people:
1. Mizrael
2. LeBron
3. Pit for LM
4. scorp
5. vbn
6. Дубровин Павел
7. Dirty Player
In this composition, the AC will function for the summer and fall season of 2009. From November 1st, we will begin discussing the results of the work and announce the start of a new election campaign.
/Thank you all who voted for me. I perceive this result not so much as personal support, but as approval of the Tournament Rules we are currently discussing. And your, friends, interest in this matter is the most important thing for me./
I sent the file with the results via e-mail to vbn. I don't know where to send it to ewgeniy, Ta Kotoraya... and Nagan-4. Please let me know.
In a few hours I will post the AC Rules of Operation on the forum for discussion. I haven't quite finished it yet
I hope we will soon receive the Creator's blessing and permission to organize a section for the Tournament Committee. The request was sent yesterday.
Each Commission will decide its own name. The NC are already deciding. And they have already started working. The interest in newcomers is encouraging.
Organizing Committees. There's no need to argue about the exact number of tournaments. We need to draw up a schedule for holding traditional tournaments - that's not difficult, communicate with potential Organizers, wait for proposals from the NC. IMHO, if tournaments differ in themes, one won't interfere with another. For example, ClanWar and a Team tournament are naturally never held at the same time. Or it is known that InterPortal and a contest for the best report are planned for the end of the year. Obviously, team competitions cannot be held simultaneously with IP. But an IP is not an obstacle for a tournament for newcomers.
It is important to discuss the format and timing of the traditional Main HeroesWorld tournament.
And one more thing. I do not like it when, in a topic discussing the Rules of tournaments, people I respect start insulting each other out of the blue. I ask you to refrain from this.
Results of the elections to the Appeal Commission of the Tournament Committee.
A total of 38 people voted: bRitvo4kA, Pit for LM, He3Hauka, Dirty_Player, Дубровин Павел, Sem 56, SpiriTT, <аноним1>, Hermit, еwgeniy, LeBron, OUTLAW, Деконтаминатор, Psyche_7, КостяN, Alex_R, redwhait, Captain, Nagan-4, vbn, Kash, Ta Kotoraya..., Mizrael, Wlk777, Oelm, Wicc, RAPER, invisible, Neoandy, Alone, Javdet, scorp, Aldegir, KobRa_RR, Revan, Lider1, Avern, Smoke_mk.
(the first number is FOR, the second is AGAINST, the third is % FOR, the fourth is % AGAINST (% rounded to tenths))
1. Alex_R - 22-10 - 57.9-26.3
2. Mizrael - 21-0 - 55.3-0
3. LeBron - 25-3 - 65.8-7.9
4. Pit for LM - 36-0 - 94.7-0
5. scorp - 23-1 - 60.5-2.6
6. vbn - 32-0 - 84.2-0
7. Дубровин Павел - 27-3 - 71.1-7.9
8. Dirty Player - 23-0 - 60.5-0
In one of the previous posts, respected Alex_R recused himself. But he expressed readiness to help the AC in its work.
Additionally, votes were cast for:
Nagan-4 - +7
invisible - +8-1
Javdet - +6
Dreamcatcher - +3
Loi - +2
ewgeniy - +2
Ta Kotoraya... - +4-4
Oelm - +1
Wicc - +1
Uran - +1
Now regarding the numerical composition. More or less specifically, 18 voters (47.4%) were FOR a "seven", 5 people (13.2%) were FOR a "five". The remaining 15 either expressed nothing at all, or formulated it as: if 5 - then for this one, if 7 - then plus ...
Based on the above, I propose to approve the composition of the AC as 7 people:
1. Mizrael
2. LeBron
3. Pit for LM
4. scorp
5. vbn
6. Дубровин Павел
7. Dirty Player
In this composition, the AC will function for the summer and fall season of 2009. From November 1st, we will begin discussing the results of the work and announce the start of a new election campaign.
/Thank you all who voted for me. I perceive this result not so much as personal support, but as approval of the Tournament Rules we are currently discussing. And your, friends, interest in this matter is the most important thing for me./
I sent the file with the results via e-mail to vbn. I don't know where to send it to ewgeniy, Ta Kotoraya... and Nagan-4. Please let me know.
In a few hours I will post the AC Rules of Operation on the forum for discussion. I haven't quite finished it yet