Rules for Heroes of Might and Magic III online tournaments on HeroesWorld.

2 Neoandy

In my opinion, it is very important that Nagan-4, due to his profession (lawyer), be included in the team. It is necessary to clearly understand what "following the letter of the law" means.

Colleague, you are clearly exaggerating my capabilities.

And perhaps the most important thing: to establish that the AK's decision in certain cases (for example, a ban for cheating, in case of disagreement from the accused - and there are also judicial errors) could be appealed in a "referendum".

I don't know, there are about 127 of us players, but how many are active? Approximately the same as those who voted, i.e., at most about forty.
Even if everyone votes unanimously, that's 30 percent, formally 50% + 1 vote is needed, which is 64 people. No, we won't get that many.
Let the AK decide, it's faster.

Also, the option of a jury trial (from a professional point of view, the best model for the forum) is interesting, where the AK is the jury, the composition of which is elected by the forum based on the personal qualities of the participants, and the final decision should still be made by professionals (a judicial panel, say, of 3 people). So that there is no AK like in the beginning of Mikhalkov's film - 12 (twelve), when everyone quickly agreed with the arguments of the "prosecutor".

Oh, it seems clear about the AK, they are chosen, they decide the issue, and that's the end of it. If it's different, there is a risk that we will drown in committees and subcommittees that will have to monitor each other. In my opinion, only the AK needs to be created, as one structure is enough for us. If they need help, there are Ta Kotoraya..., Javdet, ewgeniy, Nagan-4, etc. who can be called in for help. And that's enough, in my opinion.

At least until the end of May, think, search, discuss - give birth to the truth.

Yes, it's already the end of May. I hope that by June:
1. The players' council will urge the organizers to speed up the deadlines for the end of the Tournaments.
2. It will begin to develop a schedule of Tournaments for the rest of the year.
3. It will help me in recruiting a team for the educational project "Rookie Course", to attract new players.
4. It will conduct explanatory work on the forum that it is time for fair play online.

One of the most respected players in the Heroes world, Antal from St. Petersburg, said a very good phrase, literally: "No one has yet come up with another way to catch cheaters with saves. Checking with saves is quite sufficient and correct. I don't even think that we need to come up with anything else."
I agree with that.