Discussions on various topics. Lots of off-topic content.

The games that Vistrite listed in his post (where he asked about their differences from Morrowind) refute this statement.

For that time, such graphics were quite good. Now, not so much.
As Ar correctly pointed out, sometimes you want to immerse yourself in the game world not only through your own imagination but also with the help of graphics.
In my opinion, nowadays, old games are mostly played for nostalgia, with the exception of those that are focused on multiplayer (Heroes of Might and Magic, for example).

Well, then what is the argument about?

The argument is that Morrowind is a pretty good RPG, and not a complete disaster, as you are stubbornly trying to prove. It's wrong to focus on the negatives while ignoring the positives.