Auto-translated
Yeah, there is that aspect to it. I'm not going to defend anyone behind their back, and cheating should definitely be fought against. And I don't really believe in universal honesty. But to post two save files and accuse someone of cheating is low. And this isn't happening on the forum for the first time. If a ban is being discussed, then this should also be a reason for a ban.
The save file is certainly questionable, to say the least. But if you see questionable moments, you should immediately draw attention to them. Saying "let everyone decide for themselves" is wrong, because everyone can decide differently. For example, there's a game on the forum with comments from Alexa-R, where he suspects his opponent of cheating. And it's quite clear that his opponent revealed the map. But, still, we have to admit that the main reason for distrust now is that we're simply afraid to admit that a newbie can play at such a level. How can we, experienced online players, not be able to play like that, but some new person immediately shows us all how to play. And that's bad!
As for the save files, I would definitely use high elves, I'm not sure I could win without them. Without the upgrade, the battle is difficult, with nuances, I only figured out how to fight after the third try. In principle, one morale isn't scary for the ogres. So, I approached the hive with 7 elves, 44 centaurs, and 8 dwarves. Naturally, the loot is good. What bothered me wasn't that Smoke suspected cheating, but how he presented it.