A player with such results can only rank lower if all their wins were against newbies, and they lost to skilled players.
Now, to all the other complainers – Stinger played 1 game, Paladin – 2. This doesn't provide any objective basis for a rating. But after 10 games with equally skilled players, you can already draw some conclusions.
I'm just too lazy to read the whole thread. Can you summarize in two words what this rating is for? And what are the qualitative changes compared to the existing one?
Зима 2011-12.