What is your opinion about Heroes IV?

I remember another forum member getting heavily criticized for similar words directed at Heroes 1 and 2!
Nothing personal, but it's best to refrain from such statements on the "Heroes" forum, IMHO. It's understandable that you might not like Heroes 4, but expressing your opinion in THAT way... I don't think it's necessary.

I would still give Mantikora negative ratings for such words, because he didn't justify them, and even if he did, he could have used more polite words ("I think this game was exceptionally unsuccessful"), so the issue is more about that than the fact that he was criticizing the fourth game. Many people criticized the fourth game, and nothing happened; they didn't get a lot of negative ratings! Because they expressed themselves with arguments FIRST, and not later, when they were asked why they didn't like the game.