Attention! Floodscar 2008.

ATTENTION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Surprisingly, there are many forum users who fit this nomination; the forum is very good both in terms of casual chatting and serious discussions (especially the section dedicated to Heroes 4), but, strangely enough, when I was creating this nomination, I already knew who I would vote for...
Major Whirlwind
Whirlwind is not exactly an example of seriousness (see Creator))), and he often engages in casual chatting, but when I see that Whirlwind left the latest message in a thread, I will most likely go there, because I know that it won't be a 2-line post; it will be a detailed message with his opinion, with evidence and examples. It will be interesting to argue with him, as the discussion will be constructive and respectful to opponents, this is especially noticeable in the rather casual section about Heroes 5. I am giving my vote to Whirlwind without any hesitation.

I agree with your vote.
By the way, is this the complete list of participants?