Sergei, do you have to discuss this with everyone?
For example, I don't really care – I play for fun, and therefore I don't even look at saves, except when I'm writing a report.
But when I played with one friend, in Might and Magic, in 4 weeks he built the entire Inferno Castle, I had 3 Swamps, all without Hydras, and I barely won (the guy plays much worse than me). I suspected something was wrong, looked at the save – he just had a million of everything. Of course, it's not scary, but if you play to win, it's annoying (probably).

No, that's not what I meant, Zhenya. I look at saves myself (although not always anymore, because I don't have enough time). But I do it solely to learn how to play. When there are a million of all resources, that's one thing, but when a person has suspicions in every game, that's another. I'm not justifying anyone in any way. I'm just saying that when it's just a suspicion, it's better to keep it to yourself for the time being, but when it happens repeatedly, you can ask and make a rule. I once read a game analysis. There were also suspicious moves, he went in that direction, ended up in the right place at the right time, which led to a win. They started analyzing it, but then one well-known top player looked at the saves and said that he would have done the same. There's also such a thing as a "gut feeling" that develops stronger and stronger as you improve your game. And what seems impossible to an average player is quite normal for a pro.
In a recent game, I found myself in a situation where I came through a secondary path directly to the opponent's Castle, and the main hero was inside, and part of the troops hadn't been bought back. What would the author of the topic say after that?! Would he also create a topic inviting everyone to criticize me?! How did that happen?! Did I look at the map?! But in reality, I broke through the guard and spotted some blue units moving back and forth, and I chose the right direction based on the hero's location. And the fact that the main hero was in the Castle was a surprise to me, because I wanted to take the Castle while the enemy's hero was walking in my field of vision far from the Castle, but there was a teleport there, and I didn't notice when he returned to the Castle. Everything can be logically explained.
Judging by the saves, the accused player plays quite well, I would even say very well. That's why I asked the author of the topic right away: did you talk to him personally? Apparently not. I also had a SIMILAR conflict with Alex_R (only I wasn't honored enough to have a separate topic created for me, and if it had been created, I would have been banned after a while:)), I can give a couple more examples from his own (Alex_R) investigations and accusations. I know how unpleasant it is.
I'm saying this again, I'm not justifying anyone, I'm just expressing my opinion!