Also, here are the saves from another duel with the same player (he was playing as Valesk).
In the second duel, I think that deliberately moving towards my Castle without deviating anywhere – to make it in time for turn 1-2-1 – is a good strategy. Also, on day 5, Valesk receives 4 vampires from the Dungeon – to take the treasure with one angel (see the save "restored part...").

I'm not very good at these random maps, but they say that real pros know where everything is located, and despite the randomness, it's essentially the same for them. They also know where everything is and what might be waiting for them there. For example, when I go down a road, I often don't deviate anywhere because usually, there aren't enough of these detours:D. And then, where else could he go but to the Dungeon:p? He went, saw the treasure, and took what was there (4 vampires, why not?).
And most importantly, if he saw everything, why did he use other heroes to scout? After all, he saw everything and knew what he was taking from your Castle, so it's over; there's no need to scout anything.
And secondly, on day 5, you could have restarted because of the encounter.
In the previous round with my favorite heroes, I jumped into a portal on day 4 and ended up teleporting to my opponent, who was also looking at the map? But the opponent attacked, and there was a restart.
And in the Swamps, there are always weak creatures, at least in the 4 random maps I played.
You should have sent it to the Heroes Bay to show them; it would be interesting to see what they would say. There are no better random map experts in Russia; they constantly watch others play live and will immediately say whether something like this happens often or not.
But, to be honest, I don't really understand the desire of many on this forum to review saves. It seems that the point of the game is to find as many violations as possible after the game and protest them:smile08:. Or maybe those who play on the Tournament Edition don't have these problems:)

Added after 35 minutes
Regarding the trip to the Swamp, while I was reading, I thought he really went to the Swamp, but it turns out it's only 2 steps away, not the edge of the map:D. Again, if we assume that he was looking at the map, why did he choose the winding path to the Swamp instead of going straight to the Rampart:confused:? There are three treasures and a wood + 3 artifacts, weak guards + a level 5 creature in the Rampart, which is not in the Swamp, and you can also go from the Rampart to the Dungeon with more troops from the 3 treasures and the wood (I didn't bother and didn't check the contents of these objects; I think the others didn't either).
And you yourself didn't deviate much and didn't try to collect gold; you also went straight to the tower; did you peek at the map:D?
P.S. Or maybe I just want to justify the guy, although objectively, I don't see any reason why he shouldn't play the way he does; everyone has their own logic, and it's not always possible or worth understanding it:smile42:. Paraphrasing a silly saying: laughter without a reason is a sign of foolishness – nonsense, because not everyone is given to understand the reasons for this laughter because we are people, and people are different: with different views and upbringing, and what is funny to one is not funny to another