Expedition: general discussions.

even not to give it to the GM, but to another person

No-no... What kind of "deal" is that? Whatever the universally beloved random number generator gave, that "other person" "confirmed." In terms of stamina, you were almost evenly matched, and the random number generator gave a 50/50 chance: three times in your favor, three times in the pumpkin's favor. But as for the turns... Even with the penalty, his chance of hitting was higher than yours and Astral's...