They return to the cave. If everything is the same and the bull has healed while they were gone, the plan is as follows:
Haty starts with Stun, and Hopful doesn’t crit. If he misses, the others skip their turn. If he hits, he has 15 HP left from the reflection, the bull has 20, and Shlyapich uses his ability with the remaining Giant Arrows. If he misses, they wait for the bull to heal to full and repeat the procedure one last time. If the bull applies Shield, Dor removes it with a dagger beforehand. If it’s a miss the second time, then maybe we should create new characters.