Arandor
Auto-translated
where's the music from Disco Elysium?
Raikou (Lightning) -USHI GOZEN BATTLE- 4. is this from Wukong? the intro is too harsh and loud, hitting you in the head (in a bad way). at times there's just too much going on, in my opinion. overall, there's an overabundance of "tense" music. there are brief lulls, but that rattle grates on me for almost the entire track, and so the score is below average (average is 5, not 7 like today's game journalists)
Baldur's Gate 3 - Ketheric Thorm Battle Theme - Mix - 5. why the hell send 10 minutes? instead of sending the menu music from the second part and getting 10 points. and yes, I didn't send one of my picks because it had wailing/mumbling for 20 seconds. expect a 7-minute track next time
Heroes Of Might And Magic IV - Sea Theme - 5. why send obscure melodies from the bad parts when for nine years you could've been sending music from the HoMM 3 towns? and then HoMM 4 too.
Promise (Reprise) - 3. was hoping for the melody to develop, but that didn't happen and it stayed stagnant, just like the game series
Hermodr A Helferd - 3. I guess I sometimes worry for nothing that some of my picks have too drawn-out intros (40-50 seconds), since somewhere out there it lasts the whole track. -1 sanity
Chaos Contained - 7. finally some actual development, and you can really listen to it intentionally rather than just as background noise
DANCE MONKEY (Piano Cover) - Peter Bence - 5. for the original I'd give more x) in general, I don't really like it when people change the arrangement or tempo etc. of a melody when making a cover or just performing it on some instrument. that is, if you make a rock version, then don't change anything, just make a rock version without any of your own additions. and in other cases too. if you play on violin or keyboards, then just play it as intended. some also make some kind of jazz version, and in the end only 1 in 100 attempts turns out well, in the rest of the cases it's hard to listen to and it feels like they just st****d a couple of samples and made their own track.
Aventyr - At the Bottom of Time - 6. remembered that I have a guy who plays the harp
Glenn Proudfoot - Perfect - you asked for some guitar yourself... there was also this option, but given last year + the fact that it's partly my childhood nostalgia, I didn't choose it. but for me it's one of the top game melodies (the original is 8-bit, by the way). on VK there's an even lighter and more musical cover, but it's not on YouTube, so I only considered this one, besides the original (maybe there are better ones too).
Viima - 6. 🌖
Revolve - 7. pleasant. would've been better without the flute
Raikou (Lightning) -USHI GOZEN BATTLE- 4. is this from Wukong? the intro is too harsh and loud, hitting you in the head (in a bad way). at times there's just too much going on, in my opinion. overall, there's an overabundance of "tense" music. there are brief lulls, but that rattle grates on me for almost the entire track, and so the score is below average (average is 5, not 7 like today's game journalists)
Baldur's Gate 3 - Ketheric Thorm Battle Theme - Mix - 5. why the hell send 10 minutes? instead of sending the menu music from the second part and getting 10 points. and yes, I didn't send one of my picks because it had wailing/mumbling for 20 seconds. expect a 7-minute track next time
Heroes Of Might And Magic IV - Sea Theme - 5. why send obscure melodies from the bad parts when for nine years you could've been sending music from the HoMM 3 towns? and then HoMM 4 too.
Promise (Reprise) - 3. was hoping for the melody to develop, but that didn't happen and it stayed stagnant, just like the game series
Hermodr A Helferd - 3. I guess I sometimes worry for nothing that some of my picks have too drawn-out intros (40-50 seconds), since somewhere out there it lasts the whole track. -1 sanity
Chaos Contained - 7. finally some actual development, and you can really listen to it intentionally rather than just as background noise
DANCE MONKEY (Piano Cover) - Peter Bence - 5. for the original I'd give more x) in general, I don't really like it when people change the arrangement or tempo etc. of a melody when making a cover or just performing it on some instrument. that is, if you make a rock version, then don't change anything, just make a rock version without any of your own additions. and in other cases too. if you play on violin or keyboards, then just play it as intended. some also make some kind of jazz version, and in the end only 1 in 100 attempts turns out well, in the rest of the cases it's hard to listen to and it feels like they just st****d a couple of samples and made their own track.
Aventyr - At the Bottom of Time - 6. remembered that I have a guy who plays the harp
Glenn Proudfoot - Perfect - you asked for some guitar yourself... there was also this option, but given last year + the fact that it's partly my childhood nostalgia, I didn't choose it. but for me it's one of the top game melodies (the original is 8-bit, by the way). on VK there's an even lighter and more musical cover, but it's not on YouTube, so I only considered this one, besides the original (maybe there are better ones too).
Viima - 6. 🌖
Revolve - 7. pleasant. would've been better without the flute
Be strong. Believe