Who is he supposed to target? What's the logic? Purely logically, whether the "secondary initiative" is determined by speed, randomness, or the dragon's heartburn – it doesn't matter. So, what's the problem?
What are they wrong about? I don't understand.
If the initiative is the same, speed comes into play. If the speed is the same, something else comes into play. This isn't the ramblings of madmen. The developers of Olden Era are right.