I don't know.
But if we follow your logic, that on the 2nd night, the block was indeed from the Mafia and not the Monkey... Maybe she didn't steal rum from Heroist, but a gun, and we were all clueless the whole day? In that case, she might know who this damn Jones is...
We should find her and interrogate her thoroughly...
We execute Kraken.
6 players remain.
At night, the Mafia has a choice:
1. Jones goes to kill Will. Will protects Barbossa, Jack sends the guest to himself or another Mafia member.
Beckett saves himself.
Barbossa blocks Jones.
0 kills, we execute anyone.
2. Jones sucks on his tentacles.
Beckett goes to kill and kills a town member.
Beckett feels bad.
-2 players, 4 town members and Jones, we execute him.
3. Beckett blocks Will.
Jones kills Barbossa.
Beckett feels bad.
-2 players, 4 town members and Jones, we execute him.
We still need to figure out exactly who Jones is and who Beckett is. We have until tomorrow, so we'll have to work hard on finding evidence.
Check if I calculated everything correctly. If so, we can safely execute Kraken.