On the first night, a monkey stole from Heroist. On the second night, we have 2 blocks (one from the Mafia, the other from the Monkey). This means Heroist had a bottle of rum.
Among the peaceful roles, rum is held by Elizabeth (Locken - dead), Gibbs (definitely not Heroist, as his night action was used on him on the first night + this role is presumably with Mental), Jack Sparrow, and Cotton.
The monkey ignores the block but doesn't ignore the "leave me alone" action, so Heroist is not Jack. That leaves Cotton. I don't see Heroist in this role.
Execute Heroist.
Ничто не возникает из ничего и ничто не пропадает бесследно.
Если где-то чего-то убудет, то в другом месте добавится.
(Закон сохранения).