Skip to content

Mafia 112. Pirates of the HW Sea

User Avatar
#600
Auto-translated
I have no idea why you decided that there was no night action from the Monkey on the first night. It is clearly stated about the Heroist having holes in his pockets – it’s hard not to notice and understand that this is about stealing. And that’s what I wrote after the first night. There is also an obvious theft on the second night. And most likely, a second action. Why you decided that this must be a block – I don’t know. In my opinion, there is little benefit for the Monkey from that.
Author
The Monkey stole from the Heroist on the first night. On the second night, we have 2 blocks (one from the Mafia, the second from the Monkey). This means the Heroist had a bottle of rum.
Among the peaceful roles, rum is held by Elizabeth (Locken – dead), Gibbs (definitely not the Heroist, because his night action was on him on the first night + this role is presumably with the Mentalist), Jack Sparrow, and Cotton.

The Monkey ignores the block, but does not ignore the “leave me alone” action, which means the Heroist is not Jack. That leaves Cotton. I don’t see the Heroist in this role. If, after the execution, it turns out that he is actually Cotton, then, of course, I will apologize profusely, admit my mistake, and so on. But I highly doubt that I will have to apologize.

Execute the Heroist.
Interesting theory. I need to think about it. In principle, I am ready to support it if I don’t find anything more plausible based on the evidence.