Revan, I can't answer that question for you. I just can't. But if I could, you would understand everything.
Believe me, I had very good reasons to panic.
Lars - Tall, glasses, notebook.
Cliff - Average height, watch, wallet.
Charlie - Tall, watch, wallet.
Saltzman - Tall, watch, notebook.
Specter of the Abbot - Tall, watch, notebook
Specter of the Head Guard - Average height, wallet, watch/anything.
Specter of the Head Physician - Tall/average height, glasses, toolkit.
Combination: watch + tall + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Lars, Cliff.
No: Charlie, Saltzman, Abbot.
Combination: watch + average height + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Charlie, Saltzman.
No: Lars, Cliff, Abbot.
Combination: glasses + tall + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Saltzman, Abbot, Charlie.
No: Lars, Cliff.
Combination: glasses + average height + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Lars, Cliff.
No: Charlie, Saltzman, Abbot.
Combination: wallet + tall + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Lars, Cliff, Saltzman, Abbot.
No: Charlie.
Combination: wallet + average height + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Charlie.
No: Lars, Cliff, Saltzman, Abbot.
Combination: notebook + tall + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Charlie.
No: Lars, Cliff, Saltzman, Abbot.
Combination: notebook + average height + affiliation with a Faction
Yes: Lars, Cliff, Saltzman, Abbot.
No: Charlie.
In all or almost all combinations, the Physician and Guard are also possible, depending on whether they changed their status/items or not. If I messed something up, you can correct me, but I don't see any reason to panic if you surveyed the city in any way.