Mafia: general discussions.

but with my option, you would have had four votes,

We wouldn't have had 4 votes. The fragment would have survived: The cop would have taken the hit intended for him, after which he would have died himself (at least, Tox said so).

Also, a lot would depend on who was killed at night.

Okay, let's say you killed Humer (in my opinion, the most logical option, since you decided to isolate the Master), and so what? Since Lynx was already eliminated, they wouldn't forget about Heaven either...
OK, one of your defenses was eliminated like a newbie's. Let's say the Reaper stayed home, and your father took out your second defense. And then what? You would have raised Heaven's puppet, and that's it! You would have had another "personal" protector. HOW WOULD YOU BE ELIMINATED???

this time or next time, the villagers would agree to push for one mana execution to reduce his defense and keep him under control.

They didn't do this with 5 people in the group, but with 3, they would definitely decide to do it.

you can consider that he "gave" the victory to someone.

Personally, I didn't "give" anything. I just asked a question in the chat about what to do with you. Everyone except Lynx decided to eliminate you.

but in my opinion, you lost the will.

Here, you are probably right. After the third night, I lost the desire to do anything, especially considering the GM's indifference to the obvious violation of rule 10 by Humer and the Master...

Added after 9 minutes

In fact, it turned out that I wouldn't have been eliminated anyway, thanks to Vladik, and the situation would have been completely ambiguous.

It was written on the Cop's forehead that he would protect you with all his might...

Added after 3 minutes
And Tox, it seems, is high again...:D