Skip to content

Player rating for tournaments across all installments of Heroes.

User Avatar
#963
Auto-translated
IronAxe;113517

And at this point, Dmitry AS is simply deceiving us
A sharp phrase, once again emphasizing that you are just talking for the sake of talking. I meant all the Tournaments held on the portal in 2007 (including the ones you mentioned, named after Kanighem), where, as everyone knows, there were both skeletons and experience points. And the trick – asking the question myself and answering it myself – is very suitable for those who jump into the fray without fully understanding the situation. First, I strike (in your case, I bang my head), and then I figure it out. Although, I must admit, you did summarize and clarify this complex scheme of the emergence of various rating systems for many.
First of all, let me clarify for you, who is unintelligent in every sense, that I am advocating for a universal rating system that can both "reward" for the current Tournament and "summarize" the results of several. Your one-sided, single-Tournament system does not have this quality. For a single Tournament, absolutely any system would be suitable, since it cannot move opponents around. But when summarizing the results of several Tournaments, understandable (but not for everyone) difficulties arise.
A reasonable question arises – what is the point of a rating system that is only suitable for one Tournament? It seems that I can hear the rustling of toilet paper. AronAxe's one-sided rating sank, as you can imagine, where. Unfortunately, I must state that your creation, as sad as it sounds, cannot satisfy anyone but yourself, since any system based on logic and common sense can "summarize" one Tournament.
I wish you too would acquire these two important qualities (including for communicating on this resource); perhaps then you will bring order to your ruined Carthage.
A system that takes into account both the place taken and the difference in results is not suitable for calculating the rating based on the results of several Tournaments, since the following situation may arise, when, based on the results of 5 Tournaments:

Player 1 - 1, 1, 1, 1, 3 places
Player 2 - 2, 2, 2, 2, 1 places

Based on the mixed system, it is possible that Player 2 will be the champion (Player 1 showed a weak result for whatever reason). "Who cares" - these words can be safely applied to the author of such a rating.
If you propose a system that can eliminate this shortcoming, then we can talk about something else, using logic and common sense as much as possible.
For now, I do not see a way out of this situation, other than to calculate the rating according to the places taken. Unless we reconsider the percentage of the place and the result.
Thank you again for the story.
And one more thing – quantity does not mean quality; with time, this will come, who knows, maybe even to you.
I am looking forward to the next flare-up... that is, post :).
DmitriyAS

Кто сильнее или шаблон для сравнения городов по силе.
Различие офф-лайна в Heroes II и Heroes III.

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: artem

Users Online 2 users 1568 guests