Skip to content

Player rating for tournaments across all installments of Heroes.

User Avatar
#941
Auto-translated
IronAxe;113040
Well, if this is the norm :) Then the glitches you described in my system are just child's play compared to such a GLITCH :) And as for your case, I gave you an example with runners who run five laps; in the first four laps, one wins by a second on each lap, but then on the fifth, another overtakes him by 20 seconds — WHO WON? You've gone quiet on that :) Well, then about boxers :) Player A beat player B for 9 rounds and won on points in every single one, but in the tenth, he took a hit to the jaw from player B and didn't get up :) WHO WON? Just don't tell me about the norm :)
It would be good if you didn't end up in that "child's play" yourself. The runners led you far off-topic. Boxing: here you shouldn't take one fight, but let's say 3 fights, two of which your knockout artist lost, and in the last one, what happened, happened. Based on the results of the three, the first one won. Only 1 point is given for a victory, regardless of how it was achieved.
IronAxe;113040

I might not have been talking if I hadn't heard this specifically from the people I named. And I don't intend to come up with a rating system that depends ONLY on the place taken — imho, that's wrong for off-season.

I am not, nor do I intend to be, on the list of the "numerous group" pleading with you to do this.
IronAxe;113040

So what's the problem — I think Sage explained everything to you politely. Well, let's compare you and me. In a speed tournament on a large map, you beat me by 30 days. You get 100, I calculate based on the ratio of our results. On a small map, you beat me by 4 days. You get 100, I get it depending on the ratio of results. In the skeleton gather, you collected 1000 more skeletons than me. You get 100 rating — I get it depending on the ratio of our results. This rating, both yours and mine, will reflect the real state of affairs between us in these Tournaments, both in each individual one and in the sum of all Tournaments. Now imagine HYPERBOLICALLY (you understand the meaning of this word well) that there were only three of us, and the third one is a complete newbie. Well, in all three of these Tournaments, I would have taken SECOND PLACE (look at me, I'm a hero, for goodness sake :)) and under your glitched system, based on the results of three Tournaments, I would be trailing you in rating by very little :) But under my system, it would be more objective. So, if your proposal regarding rating by place GLITCHES even in a hyperbolic example, then it remains only to guess what it will do in reality — like "time will tell," as you love to say here (by the way, it's already telling). And I don't need to wait for anything or guess — under my system, in this example, everything will be calculated tip-top :)

Exactly, that it will be "calculated," and not show the real picture. If you've already dismissed the example I mentioned as a trifle...
IronAxe;113040


Well, you didn't guess right about the weight. I'm lighter. But as for hitting someone in the face. Well, I'm not a pacifist. All sorts of things have happened. And with my buddies, that's the only way we settle things, especially when we're drinking :) But you're not exactly naive either. Like, if you've carefully studied the threads about the rating and even write that you've almost wasted your time, then you must have seen how it was all discussed and that a bunch of people came to the opinion that both place and result need to be taken into account. And then Dmitry AS shows up and says all this is wrong — only the place should be taken into account. Like a hint that we're all complete fools here. You probably weigh exactly 150 ;)
Actually, I am not, as you put it, your "buddy," and I certainly don't allow myself to write posts in a "drunk" state.
Sorry, but I was an extra at this "celebration of life" (the rating thread), which doesn't stop me from expressing my opinion, which unfortunately for you, does not coincide with yours. There, your explanations, just as here, boil down to two prepositions "in" and "on," and oh, one more thing — your system is the very best... I hope the opinion of the "bunch of people" you mentioned changes, if it hasn't already...
Plus, I'll say that life isn't as boring with you. Take that however you want.

Added after 5 minutes
You very timely compared our tournament results. Well, for me, it is more important to simply beat you in all Tournaments than to win one by a huge margin and lose the others. And theoretically, you could put me in 1st place. This is all wrong.
DmitriyAS

Кто сильнее или шаблон для сравнения городов по силе.
Различие офф-лайна в Heroes II и Heroes III.