Both ratings are still a bit rough, so the community should ideally support both authors – both the Creator and the Gamer.
Right now, we have a chance for a bright future because, by looking at both, we can find errors faster and have a chance to fix them.

I would also suggest that those who are reviewing become more detailed in their assessments. For example, when Kamikaze points out that the Creator is missing one of his games, they should find that game and report it specifically to the Creator.
When Korovka can't find 5 of her games with the Gamer, they should send him those 5, or at least one. This will make it much easier for them to find and fix specific errors in their own work.