[ТУРНИР - SoD] "SM-masters"

Purely my IMHO. Considering that the opponent had already been in that treasure, Dima had reason to believe that the opponent had already cleared the path that Luna used. And in any case, there was no formal violation of the current rules, considering the current definition of the term "path." From the point of view of a hypothetical advantage in scouting (which the opponent is emphasizing), I repeat, with the Phoenix, Luna's dwarves are easily defeated, there is enough mana, and approximately the same number of movement points are spent. Also, I would like to remind you that there is also such a concept as "a decision in favor of justice." And justice in this case is that Dima objectively outplayed his opponent in this game. The report should be annulled, the tech should be withdrawn, an analysis of the game situation should be conducted, the opponents' chances should be assessed, and a decision should be made based on objective data (and not on the subjective, underhanded whining of a certain individual). I repeat, the judges within the same tournament allowed different decisions in the same situation. How is this even possible? Furthermore, before the start of the playoffs, I recommend making a firm decision on the rules and their interpretation. I would really not like to be in the same situation when, instead of manfully admitting defeat, the opponent starts engaging in some kind of nonsense. I have already voiced my proposal in the AK thread. For L templates, which CMK also is, the rule of mandatory clearing of guards between zones should be supplemented as follows: without clearing any guards (if the opponent has not done so earlier), it is forbidden to move FROM ONE ZONE TO ANOTHER, with the exception of cases where there is no guard at all within the hero's line of sight (5 cells). If two different paths are located next to each other, one of which is not guarded (as in Timbuktu's screenshots, for example), then the existing guard of the other path is cleared.