[ТУРНИР - SoD] "SM-masters"

But it's unclear – did the opponent jump into the Treasury with control?

He came from the other side.

Merlin essentially did the right thing by saying, looking at the map, why invent that the Dwarves are moved and that this is a bug – there is nothing like that in the rules. The rules clearly state that there can be passages without guards; here, there are three passages, but two guards (wolves and dwarves), which means that where Luna passed, there was simply no guard.

I think this is the most correct decision, especially since most of those who spoke out believe that the violation (even if we assume that it existed) is not obvious.
This was one of the first cases considered by the judges.
I repeat once again that I have serious doubts about the correctness of the decision we made.
I raised this issue because I believe that the report should be annulled.
The technical report can remain in effect, as the players are unlikely to replay this match; both will advance, one in 1st place and the other in 2nd, and I don't think that's so important.
So, the mistake is not so fatal.
It is simply important at this stage to understand how to act in similar situations in the future.
For example, the same case with Timbuktu, where he was forbidden to go down for gold:

So, you can go to the left, then down behind the mountain, but you can't run next to the archers.
Okay, let's assume that's the case; he runs around, and then the opponent comes and passes next to the archers; what then, a technical report against the opponent?
But he didn't know; he saw the opponent running from here to there, but he didn't see that he was going around and thinks that the guard was defeated.
And if it's not a technical report, then why are we forbidding the first player from running there?

Most appeals to the judges are precisely about moved guards and bugged passages.
Why not allow them to be used, especially since they are allowed on all other playable maps?
Perhaps CM (Conquest Map) is no longer played because of such a large number of controversial episodes...
I understand that you wanted to do what was best by creating this rule, to reduce the amount of freebies and make everything more balanced, but in fact, it creates a lot of controversial moments.
It turns out that a hill is generated, dividing the passage – that's it, there's a loophole to pass through, but if it's not generated, then, sorry, you're out of luck.
The same randomness!!! And you can't escape it, so maybe you shouldn't run?