[Tournaments-HotA] Game of Thrones - 2

So, if a player performed well individually (didn't lose in the tournament), is it no longer nonsensical?

No, it means the player was unlucky with their team, but that's not a reason to include them in another team that is still competing. That's just my opinion.
I've always found such replacements from already eliminated teams to be very unsportsmanlike in Vika's tournaments.