JUDGMENT

Pandora, I'm on your side, but I think this is primarily YOUR decision. Think it over...

I don't quite agree. This isn't about a personal matter, but about a violation, and not just any violation (if it were a simple violation, say, using a bug or cheating in a minor way, then it would be a personal matter).
It's a violation involving the use of cheats. Therefore, it affects everyone because he can play against anyone. That's why there's a vote to decide whether to give him a second chance so that he understands that he can't do that.
With respect.