Skip to content

Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

#1747
Auto-translated
I request the AC to look into this situation:

Tournaments "One for All", game Chemist_HP vs Faria

Mini-nost template. On 211, before jumping to the Dragon Utopia, I bought some units, grands, and wood from the growth and, via TP and DD, attacked a passing blue village with my main hero using three ones. The opponent insists on a red rush, according to rule 2.1.1 paragraph a) ...on the blue Castle (even if the Castle is not guarded)...

During the discussion of the aforementioned episode with Amiloo, it became clear that he and I have different approaches to interpreting the rules. For him, some rules must be followed strictly, while others can be supplemented and clarified if necessary. For me, all rules are equal, and if a specific situation requires clarification, then it should be provided. Therefore, I disagree with his verdict — a technical loss based on a red rush.

Thank you for your attention!
P.S. I cannot upload the save here; Amiloo has it. Just so you know, I'll be away for the weekend starting Friday