"War of the Strongest"

You're wrong, I had to ;). Apparently, Amber, you didn't check it for "that long"... There is a probability of deviations, but it repeats after a certain number of times :)

In other words, your position looks like this:

"If, based on a detailed, step-by-step description of the battle provided by the player on his save file (before the battle), the reviewer fails to achieve the specified sequence of morale drops, the battle should be considered invalid."

Is that right? And how many times does the check need to be performed to definitively state that the morale could not have dropped? Because that's what we're talking about. We're not evaluating the probabilities of morale dropping; we're discussing the mechanism for checking the save file.

Added 3 minutes later

With all due respect, Amber, this example doesn't prove anything - it's a different matter when there are a large number of monsters in your army and the enemy's army...

If the verification method doesn't work even on one of the save files, it's incorrect. And the number of units in the battle doesn't matter. The question is: can you always reproduce what has already happened, and how many attempts are needed to guarantee that it was actually what happened or not?