Skip to content
#7990
Auto-translated
Javdet
We naturally have an encounter, the turn automatically passes to the valiant Knight, and what do we have in the end: starting from the moment the turn was passed on day 127 to 132, I didn't get to make a move. There was buying, an attack, and GG.
But I liked the opponent's reaction more than his actions: "I didn't break the rules because I didn't attack on day 131, and therefore there was no redraw." That is, he doesn't care that the opponent just watched for 2 turns while he made his moves.
At first, I wanted to write to the developers, but I doubt they can change anything here. It's a matter of mentality, decency, and principles.
Javdet

The Observation Phase (OH) lasts until the 2nd month, conditionally. When they meet on day 131, Red goes first, and Blue attacks at that moment. The OH ends, and the day is replayed. BUT! This is where the main problem lies: Blue has already, as it were, made a move, but doesn't get a turn, while Red gets an extra turn on day 132.
In other words, I simply didn't get to make a move on day 131.
I don't quite understand either.
Either there's a misunderstanding of how the OH works, or it's a bug.
When in contact with the opponent during the OH, Blue's turn is rolled back, and Blue should replay it (already with up-to-date information about Red, and not with outdated information from one day ago, as during the OH).
Did you replay the rolled-back turn or not?
The encounter occurred on which day, on 131? That is, 131 was rolled back?
Did you not have day 131 at all? What is the exact sequence of events?
Example:
131 - encounter - rollback, but it didn't allow you to replay the turn.
Is that what happened?

Added 15 minutes ago
baratorch
I don't quite understand either.
Either there's a misunderstanding of how the OH works, or it's a bug.
When in contact with the opponent during the OH, Blue's turn is rolled back, and Blue should replay it (already with up-to-date information about Red, and not with outdated information from one day ago, as during the OH).
Did you replay the rolled-back turn or not?
The encounter occurred on which day, on 131? That is, 131 was rolled back?
Did you not have day 131 at all? What is the exact sequence of events?
Example:
131 - encounter - rollback, but it didn't allow you to replay the turn.
Is that what happened?


Once again: During the OH, Red moves exactly the same as without the OH - everything is identical.
But Blue - no. Blue's turn, as it were, doesn't exist during the OH.
Blue sees the state of Red not from Red's previous turn, as in the game without OH, but one day earlier.
Obviously, this is because during the simultaneous turn of Blue, Red has not yet moved. Blue always has outdated information about Red by 1 day during the OH.
Therefore, when Blue "attacks" Red during the OH, he attacks a phantom from the previous day; Red may actually be in a different place, with a different army, etc. Therefore, if Blue attacks, the turn is simply rolled back, Blue waits for Red's turn to end, and then replays the turn with up-to-date information about Red.
If, however, Red attacks during the OH, he attacks the real Blue, so Blue's turn is rolled back, and Blue accepts the battle (in the state he was in at the end of his last turn).
Is it really that hard to understand?
HoMM 3 HD:

последняя версия - 5.0 RC96 (19.09.2020)

последнее видео: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u70wC0DJ7I8

полное подробное описание