Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

I actually think it’s absurd to punish players for using replays. In other words, it turns out like this: I play a game with Dirty, let’s say it’s an HL map, so we save it on June 5th with a time of 145, for example, and continue on June 29th. I don’t remember anything and decide to use replays, which cost 1 mana each. Even if there are some games where 1-4 mana will decide the game, there will be a maximum of 2-3 of them out of 100 games (and if there was a load after viewing the replay, I don’t see anything critical in this either). In percentage terms, these games will account for ~2-3%, and remembering what the map was is actually a relevant topic.
I don’t understand why top players don’t comment on this topic here. For example, when playing with Ivan aka FireToSky, I’m sure that if he uses replays, I won’t say a word about it, knowing this. At the same time, I doubt that the opposite would happen, if I use replays, and he would criticize me for it. I think the same will happen in games with Hellight, Lizard, Homunculus, Lucky, Amilu, Amsterdam, etc. (top-level players).