Auto-translated
I only evaluate the face (especially since there are no skinny or overweight characters here; although there are some smaller ones). And, of course, I don't take into account any sympathy I might have for certain characters (if I know them), because the contest is aimed at something else, and I'm not stupid; I evaluate based on the given criteria.
1. - 2 could have worked even for a feminine-looking guy if you remove the body. It's anime, after all.
2. - 5 I don't like the style; the eyes are dull.
3. - 4 It's better here, but it's not my type. Clothes and glasses don't turn an ordinary woman into a sexy teacher.
4. - 8
5. - 1 This is an annual thing for Clover's friends. Alex said it all.
6. - 2. Seriously. I don't even know how to rate THIS. Wrong contest.
7. - 7
8. - 3 God forbid. A three only because of the comparison with other works; otherwise, it would be lower.
9. - 4 Although it's worse than the third, it's better than the eighth.
10. - 5
11. - 6
12. - 2. Yes, metal, white hair, tattoos.