Posts from Mafia 102. Veliria

Found a good option for execution.

villagers:
Soft
Snow
Ment
Niko
Fragment

negatives:
Jaconda
Eki
Gur
Dag
Kosha

I won't be looking for various cats and wizards right now, nor will I be trying to identify the villager/neutral from the five suspects I have. It's pointless, considering they are all behaving poorly. There's not much difference in who to execute and kill/block at night, as long as it's successful, without getting caught in idiotic mafia immunities and defenses.
Personally, I chose Eki because he didn't execute Uranus, plus his behavior and messages. The situation with Jaconda is similar. There's no vote, and I don't even want to remember his posts. Gur also didn't vote and was too passive, but he's clearly not the first on the list to be executed, as is Dag, who seemed like a villager to me before. From this, it turns out that the order for execution/death is as follows: Eki/Jaconda, Kosha, Gur/Dag. That's how it is.

The fewer mafia members we leave alive by night, the less chance they have to interfere with the town's night actions. But we want to have our cake and eat it too – we want to test the role of a player we simply don't like, and at the same time free ourselves from the obligation of searching for real mafia members among those who are genuinely suspicious.

Which list are you talking about? You're getting completely confused. The point is that everyone suspects a different player to varying degrees. The Detective suspects one player more, I suspect another, and so on. Some of the Mafia roles have protection, and since no one has been able to link any evidence to the suspects, we'll have to choose randomly. If they could link evidence to a suspect from the list, we would leave them for last because of Reynold's protection, who goes around killing.

That's a constructive point.
Jaconda, I'm more interested in something else. Although I admit I might have missed it. Do you think Etzit is not a mafia member? I mean, you're doubting it, according to your words. You also don't think you are one. So, who is? Suggest an alternative candidate.

I've already said, I don't like Gur.

Since we’ve started voting for the ant, I think we should finish this. Tomorrow we’ll execute Jaconda, if she’s still alive.

Based on the poll, Jaconda is either Mafia or a neutral role like Oracle or Longfair. If she's Oracle, her death won't prevent much – checking and changing her status won't significantly hinder the town's investigation. But if she's Longfair, firstly, we eliminate the Mafia's anti-protection (if they haven't used it yet), and secondly, we get rid of the traps that, as I understand it, block investigations (and they might already be in place).

Generally, it's clear that everyone sees what they want to see. I've actually been voting for Gura for a long time. "Ment," the third branch, means that a vote was opened for me; I opened it in Gura, and you opened it in Eciton. And then you'll go around guessing at the clues, while the Mafia calmly shoots each other.

Since we've started voting in the ant game, I think we should finish it. Tomorrow we'll execute Jaconda, if she's still alive.

As I already wrote, Jaconda is either Ori or Longfair. If Acetone is mafia, he might be Reynold with protection from execution. Or am I misreading the role?

Personally, I chose Eki because he didn't execute Uran, plus his behavior and messages.

Still, he has very strange posts at the beginning of the game. Didn't join the set?

I already wrote, I don't like Gur.

But in my opinion, Gur doesn't seem that suspicious. At least, no one specifically suspects him.

Right now, we're either voting for Jaconda or Eciton, right?

Well, if that's the reason, then it's worth taking a chance. I wouldn't want to execute the tester, of course, but if necessary, I'll change the voice.

Dag: execute EcitoN.

Dag, what’s up with you? People are thinking about shifting votes to Jaconda, and you…

If you're going to execute Aceton, either state why it's more beneficial to execute him specifically, rather than Jaconda, or execute him without me. I see more meaning in executing Jaconda.

Ara, what about me?

Added 51 seconds later
I don't want to ban Jackonda. Not yet.