Posts from Mafia 55. Star Wars: Clone Wars Auto-translated

Maybe the fact that the emphasis was placed on suspicion towards the end changed things.

Here, it's simple: you, as a player, are stronger and more cunning than Sub-Zero or Dimka. That's why I kept in mind the possibility that you might be a negative influence, especially since I myself have a standard, peaceful role without any special abilities.

Oh yes, I forgot about Siever. His game was fantastic, and his voice was decisive!
Zubr, and yes, poni, it was a good, solid, and strong game. And the fact that Kosha played it... well, I'm not exactly objective, am I?

Come on, don't attack me like that. It was my first game as a maniac, after all (and the third overall!), I just wasn't that familiar with the game and didn't want to give myself away, and I didn't have much time. The only thing I need to explain is my double kill. I didn't really read the description of Rimple's execution, and I figured that since I didn't have much time left (I was kidnapped, after all), I might as well have some fun with the role I was given. I had already accepted my death, and when I saw that I was still alive, I was very surprised, and I didn't really expect to win. Well, I did heal everyone... Such an interesting role ended up in such uninteresting hands...

Added 1 minute ago
And if you like to vote for the best player, then it's Tox

Added 8 minutes ago
The caricatured pictures for the roles were also pretty funny :D

I enjoyed the game. Thanks to everyone who participated :). The town did a great job. Zybr, who had such a hardcore role, showed excellent daytime play. I would choose him as the best player. I also liked Rudyy and Drakkoska from the town. Regarding the Mafia: ortonnn gave himself away too much, and in the penultimate day, I was surprised by how Nefela herself drew suspicion to herself. The Serial Killers didn't really get to play much. I want to give a special thanks to two players: Drakkoska and Tox. The first made the days more fun with constant jokes, and the second made the game more interesting and the outcome more ambiguous with an unusual move. Now about my mistakes. In the game on 1C, the clues mostly remained an element of the newspaper's design, so I didn't expect them to be deciphered so quickly. Too easy clues on the first day – that was my first serious mistake, which affected the game. Tox partially corrected it, although that was my second mistake. He deserved a modkill, but I didn't give it to him. I thought that his carelessness in his messages didn't affect the game, because he had already been exposed by the newspaper. Plus, after two bans, I didn't want to treat him harshly. I admit this mistake too, although I don't think it's appropriate to point it out to me so openly; after all, the rules state that the host decides on controversial issues, including the degree of exposure, at his discretion. I'm also interested in your opinion about the clues of the second and subsequent nights. Everything is clear with the first one. On the other hand, for the first time in my memory, players were executed based on the clues :). Congratulations to the town on a well-deserved victory!

I'm also interested in your opinion about the clues from the second and subsequent nights.

The clues are more on the easier side than the difficult side. But they are quite close to the norm. Considering that before this game, I only played as Barbarians (or guessed incorrectly, which is indirectly the same as the past) - it's even good, there was motivation.
I'm leaving for an indefinite period.

If there had been a veteran on the Mafia team, they would have definitely insisted on modkilling Tox, but since they were all on the other side, it's clear that adhering to the rules isn't necessary. It's just...

Regarding these various "modkill" situations, it's a mixed bag. When a role has already been revealed at night by some means, there's no point in hiding it. In half the cases, doing so will actually raise unnecessary suspicion. We need to reconsider the rule. Or perhaps make it so that roles aren't revealed so obviously.

Yes, I made a very silly mistake, I got carried away, and then there was no turning back. Well, and Zubr skillfully figured it out. I really liked the set, I got into it, and played with great interest.

Thanks to everyone for the game!

P.S. Tox and Ment, thank Nefela for pulling off this amazing move for fun; it was all planned, I was against it and suggested blocking Tox, but Nefela insisted on seeing what Tox would do. Overall, I think this was the main mistake of the Mafia team.

Zubr, the block doesn't say "Player A confessed to the role __". There's a moment where the host reveals the role himself, and this is different from when it's revealed by a player. The former is a side effect, the latter is intentional. The former essentially depends on the player's attentiveness, while the latter is a confirmed reveal with no room for "maneuvering."

I was against it and suggested blocking Tox.

Kosh, you lost :(

Zubr, the block doesn't say "Player A confessed to the role of __". There's a moment where the host reveals the role himself, which is different from when it's revealed by a player. The former is a side effect, while the latter is intentional. The former essentially depends on the player's attentiveness, while the latter is a confirmed reveal with no room for "maneuvering."

It doesn't require much attention. Especially with 5-10 players, at least one of them will notice and tell the others. As a result, the block either provided information for a kill or revealed a town role. Since there aren't many scenarios where there would be a logical explanation for the role not taking action.

When a role has already been revealed at night by some player, there's no point in trying to hide it.

Ah, so that's why you thought I was Mafia and even a Maniac, when everyone already knew my role. By the way, it was quite amusing. :)
Actually, I checked Nefela because she plays relatively consistently for both sides. And from the note, it's clear that I wasn't sure about her being Mafia until Zubr started attacking her.
Ruddy is also smart, but Menti... Well, it's obvious, he just had nowhere else to go.
The Mafia did well by revealing themselves one by one, instead of all at once. :)

That’s exactly what I’m saying. There should be two options. Either the block becomes an exact role check, and the result is announced by the host.
Even with the sheriff, there are always two options. But he can reveal himself. And here, the roles don’t necessarily have to be revealed to make their move. In my opinion, it’s already a plus.

Ah, so that's why you thought I was a mafia member and even a "man," when everyone knew my role. By the way, it was very amusing. :)

Well, I forgot about your block.)))

I think it's already a plus.

If we're talking about the city, then it's a huge plus, which is bad.

So, what else is there to review here?