Posts from Mafia 29. Witch Hunt

Okay, anyway, if the next game starts before May 15-16, I won't participate... If it's later, I'll definitely sign up, and don't try to talk me out of it :)

And for today, I've said everything I wanted to... So, I'll take my leave - good night everyone!

So, they didn't care about the team. :mad: Even after my death, I participated in the discussions, even when I realized that Gil's attempt to resurrect me had failed.

And rightly so, the plan was like that... and it wasn't working out very well either. It's a mystery to me how the town didn't see him as mafia, and how he didn't realize that it would be beneficial for the Demons to sway the Executioner to their side. Ah, Town, Town.

Hey, huge thanks for the game, I had a lot of fun, especially playing as the Mafia, which was surprisingly enjoyable. :) I didn't think I'd enjoy playing as the Mafia, but it turned out to be a great experience, and the team really helped make it happen. :)
I was lucky to be on a team with Aro and Jack from the start.
I had a great partnership with Aro; analyzing different strategies with such a teammate was a real pleasure. It's great when there's more than one player thinking in the Mafia, and even better when everyone thinks together and equally, rather than one person trying to catch up with the others' thought processes. :) We spent so many hours brainstorming with Aro – it was intense. :D
Jack played brilliantly in the third phase of the game – no surprise, given his experience with psychological Mafia tactics. :) Everyone fell for his act. :)
We were also lucky with a successful recruitment on the very first day – we got a strong player on our team, and it was great to play with Slonysh again. :) In fact, I saved her life because I was the one who intuitively wanted to recruit her on the first day – and it turned out my intuition was right. :)
Jack and Slonysh also helped with the analysis, and I can't fail to mention that. :)
And, of course, Vis, whom we also managed to recruit relatively easily. He played his role perfectly, distracting your attention while Jack, thanks to this, was able to play the role of a regular town player. :) Initially, Vis didn't want to play as the Mafia and was even upset to learn that he had been recruited, but he fulfilled his duties with dignity, and I thank him for that. :)
Another important thing is that no one gave up, despite the unfortunate second night – both Slonysh and Aro were killed. You now understand, by the way, why I was so eager to revive my Executioner? :D And the best part about this is that with the unsolved recruitments, it greatly contributed to my peaceful image.
So, are we ready to conquer the Vatican? :D

In general, I could say a lot more, because there was a lot of enjoyment (as well as sincere concern for the fate of the team). But I'll stop here – anyway, the whole team already knows everything. :) It was great playing with you, friends. :)

TaKo, yes, I know there was a contrast, and it was obvious, but this is my first game as the Mafia here, and I'm happy with it. :) This is one of those rare cases where I'm satisfied with my own assessment – because I know I can play better. And I know how to do it. :) Maybe I'll get another chance. Next time, don't expect to figure me out so easily. :) Although, in general, it was frustrating. If you had figured me out, why spoil the game? I understand that you figured out the recruitments simply because you knew it wasn't your block. But the town believed it. And I wasn't playing particularly brilliantly. In the end, we still won, but why spoil such a beautiful game? :) You had already lost at that point. Well, never mind, it's your choice who to kill. :)

I also want to mention Morni – I myself have played the double-voice role twice, so I understand his game. I was even upset when the Hunter killed you. Honestly. I didn't want to win like that, and we had a chance even with a live Inquisitor. We even had specific plans – we didn't expect such a turn of events. But, what can you do. :(

Thanks to everyone for the game! :)

Discussing the game is always welcome, but providing assistance with analysis and other things is not. The elimination happens not only to get rid of a player as an individual or a vote, but also as a good player, and in the situation you described, this is simply impossible.

Well, we discuss the game and analyze it with friends, right? And, by the way, in "Roger," I specifically asked the GM if we could communicate about the game with my deceased thug-protégé. He replied that it was not forbidden for the Mafia.

Well, we discuss the game and analyze it with our friends, right?

Okay, let me put it another way: let's say there's a Mafia team consisting of three new players/not very good players and one Hostor. If the Hostor is eliminated, the Mafia is likely to lose. However, if he continues to help them even as a ghost, the situation will change for the worse for the town.

Yes, Gil and I couldn't even fall asleep; we were both thinking about the Mafia.))
We made two mistakes. First, we mixed up the roles of Ling and Morny, so we killed the thief instead of recruiting him =( and then Gur and Kitz. That's why the last three recruitments were useless.

I suggested recruiting Visa because he seemed like a Hunter. Who else could have checked and killed me?!

Okay, let me put it another way: let's say there's a Mafia team consisting of three new/not very good players and one Hostor. If Hostor is eliminated, the Mafia is very likely to lose. However, if he continues to help them even as a ghost, the situation will change for the worse for the town.

And I don't disagree. :) But there are few Mafia members, and with the death of a player, they lose one of their few votes. I think this balances things out.

And on the third hand, there will always be those who want to kill Host, Ara, Gil, etc., in the first night, and everyone else will be left to die amidst the intense analysis.

But there are few Mafia members.

The Mafia is an organized team, while the town is not. That's the whole balance. A player is more often a threat as a good player than as a role holder.

Thanks to everyone for the game.

I really didn't want the demon worshippers to win :( it would have been better if the smart town had won :( I played terribly, and we all, to put it bluntly, made a lot of mistakes... Why did we have to protect each other???!!! What kind of stupidity is that???!!! It's my fault that I didn't read that the marshal, after the death of the mage, can use resurrection!!! If I had known that, I would never have defended Aves!!!!!! Because the probability that both the Mage and the Marshal would be killed in one night is low. And if one of them is killed, the other will immediately resurrect him the next night! So why did we have to expose ourselves? I said not to defend Aves! I defended only because I was afraid that they would be killed and there would be no resurrection at all. What can I say, I messed up... Vistrit, if you understood that Kitsunka was the blacksmith and the marshal was Imaris, why didn't you say that Dgak was the mafia?! Kitsunka would have blocked him!!! Damn! How frustrating to lose! I, honestly, thought until the very end that Vistrit was the mafia, and only when Imaris was already in danger did I have a bad feeling that he was too confident and categorically stated that Vistrit was the mafia, and Volk was the Marshal. Well, townspeople? If you had been more active and hadn't given up... Well, we have to admit we lost :( Alas and alack

Okay, Ling, we almost didn't make it, barely managed to finish the game. :) Now let's celebrate.

P.S. But overall, I'll consider it a win that I managed to convince the hunter about Morning's mafia connections... I didn't think anyone would believe it, especially a hunter...

Vistrit, if you knew that Kitsunka was a blacksmith and a marshal – Imaris, why didn't you say that Dgak was a mafia member?!

Because Vistrit was recruited by us. Why would he expose us? That would be against the rules. The purpose of the recruitment would be lost in that case.

Because Vis was recruited by us. Why would he betray us? That wouldn't be fair play. The point of recruiting him would be lost in that case.

Ah... Then I have no further questions.

Thanks everyone for the game.

I really didn't want the demon worshippers to win :( I'd rather have seen the smart town win :( I played terribly, and we all, to put it bluntly, messed up a lot... Why did we have to protect each other??? What kind of stupidity is that???!!! I'm to blame for not reading that the Marshal, after the Magister's death, can use resurrection!!! If I had known that, I would never have defended Aves!!!!!! Because the probability that both the Magister and the Marshal would be killed in one night is low. And if one of them is killed, the other will immediately resurrect him the next night! So why did we have to expose ourselves? I said not to defend Aves! I defended only because I was afraid that they would be killed and there wouldn't be a resurrection at all. Well, I messed up... Vistrit, if you understood that Kitsunka was the blacksmith and the Marshal was Imaris, why didn't you say that Dgak was the Mafia?! Kitsunka would have blocked him!!! Damn! How frustrating to lose! I, honestly, thought until the very end that Vistrit was the Mafia, and only when Imaris was already "burning" did I have a bad feeling that he was too confidently and categorically asserting that Vistrit was the Mafia and Volk was the Marshal, not allowing any objections. Well, townspeople? If you had been more active and hadn't given up... Well, we have to admit we lost :( Alas and alack.

Honestly, I'd rather have the Mafia win. I should have been eliminated on some night, and then resurrected at the end; I just didn't think of it because I'm inexperienced. But overall, Hermit, do you really think we played very badly?

And I think so.